Aleppo Pepper vs Gochugaru: Which Flake Fits Your Dish?
Gochugaru
Aleppo pepper and gochugaru are both dried red chile flakes, but what goes into each jar changes how they cook. Aleppo pepper is listed at about 10,000 Scoville Heat Units (SHU), is usually sold with salt and oil worked in, and tastes tart and fruity, so it suits finishing eggs, dips and grilled meat. Gochugaru runs 1,500 to 10,000 SHU, is sun-dried and ground plain, and is the flake kimchi, Korean stews and gochujang are built on. A 1:1 swap works for a sprinkle, while in kimchi Aleppo can make a batch about 2.5 times hotter than mild gochugaru would.
Quick Comparison
| Attribute | Aleppo Pepper | Gochugaru |
|---|---|---|
| Flavor | Fruity, tart, lightly salty | Smoky and sweet |
| Mixed into the flakes | Salt and oil | Sold as plain ground pepper |
| Grind | One flake size | Coarse or fine |
| Main job | Finishing cooked food | Kimchi, stews, gochujang |
What Is in Each Jar, and How Do They Taste?
A jar of Aleppo pepper usually holds more than chile. The pods are dried, crushed rather than ground, and sold with most of the seeds sifted out, and Penzeys describes its own jar as a Turkish crushed chili treated with salt and sunflower or cottonseed oil. That salt is why you should season lightly after sprinkling it on, as Cook's Illustrated advises.
The Turkish origin is common now. When the war in Syria cut off supplies, sellers turned to peppers grown just across the border, and National Geographic's report on the spice describes the flakes as lightly salty and oily, with a whiff of wine and smoke.
Because nothing is mixed into gochugaru, a spoonful adds color and heat to your pot without salting it, so recipes can call for it by the cup, as kimchi does.
Their flavors part ways on tartness. Cook's Illustrated tasters picked up an almost raisin-like sweetness in Aleppo with a slow-building heat, and Penzeys compares it to ancho with a little more heat and tartness.
Which Grind Should You Buy?
Gochugaru is sold in more than one grind, and the bag usually says which. Coarse flakes are the everyday Korean grind and the one most kimchi and spicy stew recipes mean, as the Korean recipe site Kimchimari explains. Fine powder, called goun gochugaru, goes mainly into homemade gochujang and sometimes into tteokbokki or jjamppong for a smoother sauce, so buy coarse unless your recipe names fine.
Aleppo usually comes in a single flake size. Cook's Illustrated notes it is ground finer than ordinary crushed red pepper, which helps it spread evenly when you scatter it over eggs or pizza.
Is Gochugaru Hotter Than Aleppo Pepper?
Both flakes top out near the same Scoville number, so the answer depends on which bag of gochugaru you hold. Aleppo is listed at a single heat level, while Korean red pepper powder is sold in grades. A 2020 database study pooled 94 lab measurements of Korean powders and sorted them into five heat groups by their capsaicinoid content.
Converting Aleppo's listing into the same lab unit lets you place it among those groups. Scoville units are roughly capsaicinoid parts per million multiplied by 15, the factor used in a published HPLC method, so 10,000 SHU works out to about 67 mg of capsaicinoids per 100 g of flakes. That puts Aleppo level with a medium-hot gochugaru.
| Korean powder group | Average capsaicinoids, mg per 100 g | Aleppo at about 67 mg |
|---|---|---|
| Mild | 26 | About 2.5 times hotter |
| Slightly hot | 46 | About 1.5 times hotter |
| Medium hot | 59 | About the same |
| Very hot | 87 | About three-quarters as hot |
| Extremely hot | 154 | Under half as hot |
Before any swap, find the heat grade printed on your gochugaru bag, because that grade decides which row of the table applies to you.
Can You Use Aleppo Pepper Instead of Gochugaru in Kimchi?
You can, as long as you work out the heat first, because kimchi uses far more flake than any sprinkle. Recipes vary, from 84 g of gochugaru for 2.7 kg of cabbage in America's Test Kitchen's cut napa cabbage kimchi to 80 g for 2 kg in our gochugaru kimchi recipe. The 2020 database study put red pepper powder at about 2.2 percent of napa cabbage kimchi by weight.
At that share, Aleppo gives fresh kimchi about 1.5 mg of capsaicinoids per 100 g, against about 0.6 mg for the same recipe made with mild gochugaru. Korea's agricultural quality service labels napa cabbage kimchi above 1.2 mg as hot and 0.4 to 1.2 mg as moderately hot, so the Aleppo batch starts in the hot band. Fermentation removes roughly 20 percent of the capsaicinoids from both batches, which leaves the gap between them unchanged.
If your recipe was written for mild gochugaru, use about 40 percent of the flake weight as Aleppo and make up the rest with sweet paprika, which adds red color with very little heat. The gochugaru versus paprika comparison covers how paprika behaves in a seasoning paste.
- Start from the gram weight. Use the recipe's weight if it gives one, 84 g in the America's Test Kitchen batch, and convert your split from that.
- Split it about 40 to 60. For that batch, 33 g of Aleppo and 51 g of sweet paprika matches the heat of mild gochugaru. A recipe written for medium-hot gochugaru can take Aleppo 1:1.
- Keep the brining salt as written. Even if a tenth of the Aleppo were salt, 84 g would add about 8 g, small beside the 216 g of salt that recipe uses on the cabbage.
- Taste the paste before it meets the cabbage. If the paste already burns, the kimchi will too, since fermentation takes off only about a fifth of the heat, so add paprika first.
Can Gochugaru Replace Aleppo Pepper on Finished Food?
On finished food the swap is easier, because a pinch carries little heat either way. Cook's Illustrated uses Aleppo on pizza and eggs, in garlic-and-oil pasta, in rice pilaf and in a steak rub, and coarse gochugaru can go into each of those 1:1.
What the dish loses is Aleppo's salt and oil. Add a small pinch of salt with the gochugaru, and when the flakes go onto dry food such as eggs or flatbread, toss them first with a few drops of olive oil so they carry some of the oil that Aleppo flakes come with.
Check the heat grade on your bag before you measure. A mild or slightly hot gochugaru lands below Aleppo, which leaves room to add a little more. A very hot bag already runs hotter, so start with about three-quarters of the amount.
Which One Should You Keep in Your Pantry?
If you only want one jar, let the dish you cook most often decide, since each flake needs adjusting before it can stand in for the other.
Kimchi, stews such as sundubu jjigae and gochujang marinades all start from it, and one coarse bag covers nearly all of them. The guide to peppers in Korean cooking shows where else it goes. For long storage, keep it sealed in the fridge or freezer, and replace it once the bright red fades.
If most of your chile goes on at the table, onto hummus, yogurt, eggs or grilled meat, Aleppo does that job straight from the jar, and its salt means you add less of your own. If the jar runs out, the Aleppo pepper substitutes page lists what else works.
Aleppo Pepper vs Gochugaru FAQ
Yes, in smaller amounts. Crushed red pepper is listed at 15,000 to 45,000 SHU, hotter than either flake in most bags, and Cook's Illustrated describes its heat as straightforward, without Aleppo's sweetness. Start with half the amount, and see gochugaru versus red pepper flakes before you use them in kimchi.
Maras pepper, another Turkish flake, is the usual choice. When Syrian Aleppo became hard to get, chef Ana Sortun switched to Maras, as National Geographic reported in 2014, and Aleppo versus Maras compares the two.
- Aleppo Pepper - Cook's Illustrated (America's Test Kitchen)
- Aleppo Pepper - Penzeys Spices
- How the Syrian Conflict Affects Your Spice Rack - National Geographic (Maryn McKenna, 2014)
- Coarse Chili Powder (Gochugaru) - Kimchimari
- Mat Kimchi (Cut Napa Cabbage Kimchi) - America's Test Kitchen
- Cho & Kwon 2020, Development of a database of capsaicinoid contents in foods commonly consumed in Korea, Food Science & Nutrition 8(8):4611-4624
- Forster & Altmaier 2013, Simple and Fast Quantification of Capsaicinoids in Hot Sauces, LCGC International





