Pepper comparison

Aji Amarillo vs Lemon Drop: How Much Hotter, and Can You Swap Them?

Orange Aji Amarillo peppers with one sliced pod showing elongated shape

Aji Amarillo

C. baccatum
Hot
30,000–50,000 SHU
Yellow Lemon Drop peppers with one sliced pod showing elongated shape

Lemon Drop

C. baccatum
Hot
15,000–30,000 SHU
Aji Amarillo is about 1.8× hotter
Midpoint of each SHU range: 40,000 vs 22,500
Scoville Heat Units (SHU), log scale

Aji Amarillo is hotter than Lemon Drop, though not by much. Aji Amarillo is listed at 30,000 to 50,000 Scoville Heat Units (SHU) and Lemon Drop at 15,000 to 30,000 SHU, so gram for gram a typical Aji Amarillo carries about 1.8 times the heat. Both are Peruvian Capsicum baccatum peppers, but Aji Amarillo's long orange pods are blended into creamy sauces such as huancaína, while Lemon Drop's small yellow pods add citrus-scented heat to salsa, ceviche and pepper jelly.

Quick Comparison

Attribute Aji Amarillo Lemon Drop
Pod 5 to 6 in, tapered 2 to 3 in, conical
Ripe color Deep yellowish orange Clear lemon yellow
Plant height (seed catalog) About 5 ft About 2 ft
Days from transplant to ripe pods (seed catalog) About 85 About 100
A pile of long orange Aji Amarillo pods beside a pile of shorter yellow Lemon Drop pods on a gray surface

Why Can a Lemon Drop Taste as Hot as an Aji Amarillo?

The 1.8 figure in the summary uses the middle of each range, 40,000 SHU for Aji Amarillo and 22,500 for Lemon Drop, and the swap amounts below are built on it. The 1.7× badge on the cards compares the tops of the two ranges instead, which gives nearly the same answer.

Those ranges meet at 30,000 SHU, so a hot Lemon Drop and a mild Aji Amarillo can burn the same. New Mexico State University names genetics, weather, growing conditions and fruit age as the factors that move a pod's capsaicinoids. Taste a sliver from each new batch before you scale a recipe up.

You can make either pepper milder by cutting out the pale ribs. That tissue, the placenta, held more capsaicinoids than the flesh or the seeds in a 2021 study of 21 chili cultivars, yet it made up only 12% of the dry weight of the C. baccatum fruits tested. Taking it out lowers the heat while you keep almost all of the pepper.

How Many Lemon Drops Replace a Tablespoon of Aji Amarillo?

Start with about six Lemon Drop pods for each tablespoon of fresh Aji Amarillo purée, blended rather than chopped. That count assumes a tablespoon of purée weighs about 15 g, both peppers sit mid-range, and each Lemon Drop weighs 4.3 g, the average pod weight in the 2021 study. Across the full ranges the match runs from three or four pods to about twelve.

Six Lemon Drops weigh about 27 g, close to twice the purée you are replacing, and a creamy sauce made with them comes out looser and a paler yellow. In a huancaína-style sauce, hold back part of the milk and add it after blending only if the sauce needs thinning.

Jarred paste needs a lower start because the jar is rarely all pepper. US labels list ingredients from heaviest to lightest, and any water, salt or citric acid listed after the pepper takes up part of every spoonful.

Your recipe calls forUse insteadThen adjust
1 tbsp jarred Aji Amarillo paste4 Lemon Drop pods to startTaste, then add a pinch of salt or a squeeze of lime if the sauce tastes flat
5 Lemon Drop pods in a hot sauce (about 22 g)About 12 g Aji Amarillo, just under 1 tbsp of puréeExpect a fruitier, more orange sauce
1 Lemon Drop chopped into ceviche or salsaA slice of Aji Amarillo weighing about 2.5 gTaste before you add a second slice

For any other amount, multiply an Aji Amarillo weight by 1.8 to get the Lemon Drop weight, or divide a Lemon Drop weight by 1.8 to go the other way.

Does Lemon Drop Taste Like Lemon, and Aji Amarillo Like Fruit?

Both peppers belong to the Capsicum baccatum family, whose aroma chemists describe as generally light. A 2022 analysis of 17 chili peppers traced the baccatum samples' scent mainly to compounds with green and yellow apple notes.

Each pepper adds its own note to that base. Baker Creek, which sells Lemon Drop seed, describes a light citrus sparkle in its heat, and Sandia Seed sells Aji Amarillo on its fruity flavor. A 2011 study of Andean ají found earthy, vegetable and bell-pepper-like aromas beside fruity esters. Expect Aji Amarillo to taste rounder and more savory than the simple, bright heat of Lemon Drop.

Lemon Drop's lemon character comes without extra sourness. In the 2021 cultivar study, the three C. baccatum peppers, Lemon Drop among them, held about 35 to 42% less total organic acid than the C. annuum peppers such as jalapeño and serrano, so your ceviche or salsa still needs its full measure of lime or vinegar.

Which Dishes Need Aji Amarillo, and Which Suit Lemon Drop?

Peruvian sauces use Aji Amarillo in quantity, as the base. PromPerú's home recipes for Peruvian classics blend five boiled, deveined pods with half a cup of oil and 14 oz of fresh cheese for papa a la huancaína, and they stir half a cup of the pepper into ají de gallina.

Lemon Drop works at a smaller scale. Baker Creek lists its conical pods as thin-walled with few seeds, so a handful seasons a dish without adding much flesh, and chile author Dave DeWitt notes that small yellow baccatums are prized for their lemony aroma in fresh salsas.

Check how your recipe uses the pepper. If it is blended into the base, Aji Amarillo gives the color and body the dish was written around. If it is chopped in near the end, Lemon Drop gives you heat and citrus aroma with less flesh to cook down.

Where Aji Amarillo carries the dish

Papa a la huancaína, causa and ají de gallina, where the purée is blended with cheese, potato or bread and colors the whole plate yellow-orange.

Where Lemon Drop fits

Pepper jelly and preserves, which Baker Creek singles out for this variety, plus fresh salsa and ceviche, where a few chopped pods season a whole bowl.

How Do You Make Paste From Either Pepper, and How Long Does It Keep?

Homemade paste follows the order in PromPerú's huancaína recipe, where the pods are boiled and deveined before they go into the blender. The same steps work for Lemon Drop, which lets you replace a jar of Aji Amarillo paste with a batch from your own plants.

  1. Put on gloves. Poison Control advises rubber, latex or nitrile gloves for any work with hot peppers, and deveining puts your fingers in the hottest tissue.
  2. Boil the pods until soft. Soft pods split open easily and blend smoothly.
  3. Remove ribs and seeds. Open each pod and scrape out the pale ribs with a spoon, since that tissue holds the most capsaicinoids.
  4. Blend with a little oil. Add oil a spoonful at a time until the paste turns smooth.
  5. Portion it right away. An ice cube tray lets you thaw one tablespoon at a time, which matches the swap amounts above.

Should You Grow Lemon Drop or Aji Amarillo, or Buy Paste?

Lemon Drop suits a patio better, because by the seed catalogs' figures in the table above its plant grows less than half as tall. It fits a large container, while Aji Amarillo grows into the tall, multi-stemmed kind of plant that DeWitt compares to a small tree.

Neither pepper ripens quickly. Sandia Seed's count for Aji Amarillo runs about two weeks shorter than Baker Creek's for Lemon Drop, both from transplant, and Sandia advises waiting until the pods turn yellowish orange for the best flavor and heat. In a short summer, give both the earliest indoor start you can. The Lemon Drop growing advice covers seed starting and pot size in more detail.

If you need Aji Amarillo for a single Peruvian dish, a jar of paste skips the growing season. You can also read about fresh, frozen and dried Aji Amarillo before you shop. When neither pepper suits the dish, the Aji Amarillo substitutes list ranks other options. For far more heat, compare Aji Amarillo against habanero.

Editorial Review
Editorial Standards: Heat levels, substitutions, and core comparison claims are checked against available source material before publication.
Review Process: Prepared by KnowThePepper Editorial Team (Editorial review desk). Last updated November 12, 2026.

Aji Amarillo vs Lemon Drop FAQ

No. USDA's GRIN taxonomy lists aji limo as a Peruvian name for Capsicum chinense, the habanero species, while Lemon Drop is a C. baccatum like Aji Amarillo. The names are close enough to cause mix-ups, so check the species on the seed packet before you buy anything sold as aji limo.

GRIN lists ají amarillo, ají escabeche and ají mirasol among the Peruvian common names for Capsicum baccatum var. pendulum, the botanical variety Aji Amarillo belongs to, so a Peruvian recipe may use any of them. None of those names refers to Lemon Drop, which seed sellers offer under its English name.

All Comparisons Browse Peppers Scoville Scale